HALL OF FAME
| 1991 | * | R.M. “Dick” Brewer | | 2000 | * | “Dub” Barnes | | 2010 | * | Garry Hostetler |
| | | Bob Thummel | | | * | Curt Cole | | 2011 | | Wayne Pagel |
| 1992 | * | L.E. “Gene” Watson | | 2001 | * | George Worrell | | 2012 | | Mike Gatlin |
| | * | Earl M. Brown | | | | Gary Potter | | 2013 | | Don Hamit |
| 1993 | * | Milton Anderson | | 2002 | | Charles Beatty | | 2014 | * | Jerry Pitney |
| | * | Bing Carter | | | | Vern Gannon | | 2015 | | Jack Newcom |
| 1994 | * | Floyd Gehring | | 2003 | | Tom Lindsay, Sr. | | | | Lester Edgecomb |
| | * | Fred Sherlock | | | * | Ralph Smith | | 2016 | | Buddy Griffin |
| 1995 | * | Dale Clayton | | 2004 | | Vern Koch | | 2017 | | Wayne Wischropp |
| | | Larry Theurer | | | | Jerry Stricker | | 2018 | | Rick Brock |
| 1996 | * | Lawrence Welter | | 2005 | | Ron Shivers | | 2019 | | Rick Garvin |
| | * | Robert Wilson | | | | Ron Gingerich | | 2020 | | Jim Hollinger |
| 1997 | * | Ronald Scott | | 2006 | | John Omli | | 2021 | | – – – – |
| | * | Roy Wood | | | * | Richard Schoen | | | | |
| 1998 | * | Dick DeWeese | | 2007 | | Lonn McCurdy | | | | |
| | | Leland Boesker | | 2008 | | Bill Oswalt | | | | |
| 1999 | | Loren T. Thiele | | 2009 | | Marvin Knopp | | | | |
| | | Rex Newcom | | | * | John Shoemaker | | | | |
* Deceased
AWARD OF DISTINCTION
| 2007 | | Harland Unruh | | 2010 | | none | | 2015 | | Wayne Wischropp |
| 2008 | | Allyn Thompson | | 2011 | | Rick Brock | | 2016 | | Andy Conser |
| 2009 | | Richard Garvin | | 2012 | | Aaron Traffas | | 2017 | | Lance Fullerton |
| | | | | 2013 | | None | | 2018 | | LaDonna Schoen |
| | | | | 2014 | | Jean Oswalt | | 2019 | | Daniel Gutierrez |
| | | | | | | Dorothy Koch | | 2020 | | Bobby Hightree |
| | | | | | | Carol Stricker | | 2021 | | – – – – |
